Opposites attract but don't get along. Can a dusty box of old love letters change everything? Sensible librarian Gemma Valentine helps close her family's antique store and enjoy Cupid's Corners' Valentine's Day festival celebrating romance and weddings - even if she doesn't believe in love. But when she's tricked into briefly reviving the town paper's Dear Cupid advice column, with her best friend's too handsome brother as part of the deal, she's miffed. Why does he have to disturb her nice, tidy life? Architect and hometown football hero Sean McCleary's promotion hinges on renovating Gemma's building into a sleek, trendy retail space fast. He's willing to do anything to finish this project even provide a man's perspective for the lovelorn column. Why not? Gemma might be annoying, but she's funny and adorable and he enjoys their spirited banter. Soon Sean sees Gemma in a new light and wonders if he can convince her to give him a chance. Can two Cupid columnists take their own advice on falling in love?